MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Auto Insurers Lose Loyals

Shopping surge for better premiums seen, even among longtime policy holders

August 20, 2025
Auto Insurers Lose Loyals

Shopping for auto insurance rose 18% in the second quarter, double the bump among home insurance shoppers.

Credit:

Pexels/Jonathan Cooper

1 min to read


Auto insurance policy holders appear to be getting less loyal as premiums increase, new data show.

A TransUnion survey found that 42% of shoppers in the segment switched insurers in the past year and a half, and a quarter of those who switched in the past six months left insurers they’d been with for six years.

Baby boomers and members of generation X made up the greatest number of the formerly longtime customers who switched loyalties, TransUnion said.

Shopping for auto insurance rose 18% year-over-year in the second quarter, double the bump among home insurance shoppers, the consumer credit reporting agency said.

“It’s possible that we’ll see the growth in auto insurance shopping continue to decline as many consumers have already secured lower premiums,” said Patrick Foy, senior director of strategic planning for the company’s insurance business. 

“However, property insurance premiums continue to rise, so consumers will likely shop for less expensive alternatives. That may also prompt many to shop for auto insurance because for many customers, bundled policies remain key to overall savings.”

Insurers could increase loyalty by reaching out to policy holders when they get quotes from competitors or approach life changes, such as shopping for new vehicles, TransUnion advised.

DIG DEEPER: The Self-Insurance Challenge

More F&I

StoneEagle logo beside a headshot of Cindy Allen, CEO, on a pink background with a stylized upward-trending chart.
Industryby StaffDecember 5, 2025

EV Surge Shows AI Steadied Softer Q3

StoneEagleData reveals the gross reality behind the rise in EV leasing and the steady role F&I offices played.

Read More →
Two people signing auto insurance paperwork
Industryby Lauren LawrenceNovember 26, 2025

Auto Insurance Rates Dip

Insurers are shifting their focus from raising rates to customer satisfaction.

Read More →
F&Iby Hannah MitchellNovember 11, 2025

Autos With the Lowest Insurance Costs

Ranking intuitive in many ways, but there are many factors

Read More →
Ad Loading...
F&INovember 10, 2025

Singing a Gospel Song Backward

Crime and punishment in auto retail and how to avoid them

Read More →
Industryby Hannah MitchellNovember 3, 2025

Q3 Auto Loans Reveal Stress

Data reflect growing finance activity on the extreme ends of credit risk scale

Read More →
F&Iby StaffOctober 15, 2025

The F&I Agent's Roadmap: Mastering the Cold In-Store Visit

Register for Allstate's FREE webinar on Oct. 21

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Technician polishing a car headlight with a microfiber cloth, representing Protective Asset Protection’s enhanced Appearance Protection program for long-term vehicle surface care.
Product & Technologyby StaffOctober 8, 2025

Paint-and-Fabric Offering Upgraded

Protective Asset Protection has expanded its coverage into a comprehensive appearance-protection program featuring ceramic and graphene options for long-term vehicle care.

Read More →
Product & Technologyby Hannah MitchellSeptember 22, 2025

F&I Still Revved Up in Q2

StoneEagle data show growth and products’ outsize role in profit protection.

Read More →
Industryby Hannah MitchellSeptember 10, 2025

Auto Insurance Rates Bring Record Shopping

Many, including longtime policy holders, search for better deals.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
F&Iby Hannah MitchellSeptember 3, 2025

Undone Recall Repairs Trimmed

Initiative works with state bodies with auto touchpoints to encourage resolutions.

Read More →